Modern Times (2006)
Tracks (Click song title for lyrics)
Album Info
Modern Times is Bob Dylan's 32nd studio album, released on August 29, 2006 by Sony BMG.
The album was Dylan's third straight (following Time out of Mind and "Love and Theft") to be met with nearly universal praise from fans and critics. It continued its predecessors' tendencies toward blues, rockabilly and pre-rock balladry, and was self-produced by Dylan under the pseudonym "Jack Frost". Along with the acclaim, the album sparked some debate over its uncredited use of choruses and arrangements from older songs, as well as many lyrical lines taken from the work of 19th century poet Henry Timrod.
Modern Times became the singer-songwriter's first #1 album in the U.S. since 1976's Desire. At age 65, Dylan became the oldest living person at the time to have an album enter the Billboard charts at number one [1] (Neil Diamond has since earned the title). It also reached #1 in Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Ireland, Denmark, Norway and Switzerland, debuted #2 in Germany, Austria and Sweden. It reached #3 in the UK and The Netherlands and has sold over 4 million copies worldwide. As with its two studio predecessors, the album's packaging features minimal credits and no lyric sheet.

Comments
GRAN DISCO
Me gusta, aunque no tanto como su anterior album. workingmans-blues-2 y someday bay son mis preferidas
I like
A very good album. Maybe the best since Blood on the tracks. workingman´s blues shows that Dylan still is one of the best song writers. I rely love the sound on this album, a mystic sound.
Modern times
Very enjoyable listening. Very smooth music. Best ever album? That's some cowboy band. Is there another album in the works? I was traveling on the Washington coast , radio channel surfing . Thunder on the Mountain came on the radio. What a bonus. Had to get the album. 16 bucks!!!!!!!!!! Worth every penny. Make some more Bob.Keep it up. don't go getting old.
He's Certainly on a Roll
Workingman's Blues emerged as one of my favorite Dylan songs immediately upon the first listen. Thunder of course is great and a show stopper live.
I really like them all for one reason or another except that I could do without When the Deal Goes Down and really don't need to hear that song or Beyond the Horizon live.
Dave
Great album
No Rating
The first time I heard this album I did not think it was very good. bt then i listened to it a second time and loved it.
Modern Times
I listened to this Cd right after it came out. I am not a muscial genius but knew this had to be number one. The words are powerfull and the musical frame a delight. The honesty in this Cd is plain and simple in a very complex manner. I can feel him savoring every sylable as not to loss the taste of this delicate morsel. Anyone could believe in love after hearing this tribute to love. Whether it is, as one person reviewed from the Jewish state to God or from a man to a woman, it is a raw honest belief. I read what the others have to say and it made me a little sad. Because, if it is true that the last song is a goodbye to this love it would be a tragedy. I am the world's hopless romantic and will not see it that way. But to get back to the Cd, it is awesome. I look at muscians as I would (funny Bob is both) a painter. They first learn classical art before they have the right to abstract and they evolve over a period of years to develop their own style. But this man tops the bill. He has many styles and all great. As far as understanding exactly what he means at times this I do not even pretend to have a clue. I believe only he can answer that. I can only say that words in this particular Cd hit home with me. It is not improtant which ones because I am sure I am not the only one. I have noticed over the years that there is a max to what some people can learn or understand and then they shut down (stop evolving). You my man seem in this aspect to be only in the middle of this process. God bless!
Modern Times
Sure this is great, in 2006 there are not many left to make such an impressive statement on record - i specially appreaciate the fact that many young folks are still diggin music from such an "old" man. By the way - if this is the official Dylan site, why there are not much more comments from fans of this awesome body of musical work?????
Awesome.
Awesome.
MODERN TIMES: A LOVER'S COMPANION TO EVERYTHING
Lyrically MODERN TIMES is Dylan's strongest. Many listeners might find it uneven and prefer certain songs over others; I find it the best crafted Dylan album after “LOVE AND THEFT”. Being by far the richer composition, this superbly titled album should enjoy the accolades which BLOOD ON THE TRACKS has been receiving for decades. MODERN TIMES are in the poet’s chronicles, which began with WORLD GONE WRONG.
There is a woman’s face which follows Dylan’s recent compositions much like the solitary human who commands them. In MODERN TIMES there are two women or two versions of the same, depending on how the poet wants to look at her or himself. Much of the unevenness is caused by the doublets, love as youth and love as age; I prefer to take them as the same face. I turn to Eugenio Montale for poetry of similar dedication to a beloved but there is a difference in the playfulness and pain of the two poets and the difference is folk blues, the road, which makes the poet’s promises sometimes hard to believe or should I say they are not promises at all but seductions.
The dedicated audience of Dylan’s earlier albums must be in awe with MODERN TIMES. The composition Blind Willie Mc Tell has become a classic, in MODERN TIMES you might find those martyrs and legends which Dylan speaks of in the song. They happen to become legends by composing albums like MODERN TIMES.
What is new about MODERN TIMES? After “LOVE AND THEFT” the poet is at ease, he wears his heart as he pleases. The voyeur from “LOVE AND THEFT” has looked upon something and adjusted to it. He has found the youthful face of his beloved and he would go on telling it to her aged face for the rest of his time. Since a consummation of their new love has become impossible, the poet turns to what he knows he has possessed and makes it new.
Suggestions about the references which MODERN TIMES makes to various works don’t interest me. One can imagine what one pleases besides an amazing amount of these references can be dug up and argued for. I might go on to argue that "LOVE AND THEFT" is drawn out of Bhagavad-Gita and that Hart Crane and Tennessee Williams might have enjoyed TIME OUT OF MIND together; you have to be interested in listening. The heaven or horizon in the album is what Shelley wrote for in his Epipsychidion, the pebbled shore of faint kisses. In the album lies a great hope, one that of finding the beloved in time to come; there is strength which is keeping them alone and well but what separates them is a withering levee in the poet’s mind. If such a union takes place for the poet, he might write a Paradiso after the two volumes of his Purgatorio in folk blues.
It gets better the more I listen to it
It's not his best, but I really love "Workingman's Blues #2." I replayed that song a few times when I first heard it. Overall, it's a good album.
Least favourite
No Rating
Agreed
least favorite
No Rating
Modern Times is my least favorite Dylan album. I'm not saying its the worst Dylan album, just my least favorite. I do think when years pass it will display few redeeming qualities, unlike some of his more poorly received albums
Another triumph
I reviewed this album for www.welikemedia.com. Here is the review:
I’m listening to Bob Dylan’s new album Modern Times as I write this. I am a Bob Dylan fan. I have seen him live ten times. I own every commercial album that’s been released. I have several bootlegs and live performances. Needless to say, I get excited when new Bob material hits the shelves.
I became a fan in the mid-90s when I finally broke down and bought a copy of Freewheelin’ solely based on the cover. Shortly after I discovered this record, Bob was in the hospital and the gloomy Time Out Of Mind was released. Bob recovered, got back on the road, and all was well again. On September 11, 2001, Bob gave us Love And Theft. After that day’s tragic events, it was somehow comforting to hear Bob singing, "Today has been a sad and lonesome day…" after I finally shut off the TV and news reports of the day’s chaos and destruction. Love And Theft is easily one of my all-time favorite albums, not just by Bob, but by anyone. This is from a man who loves a lot of different albums.
So, after ten shows, several CDs, DVDs, and books, here I sit listening to Bob singing "Spirit On The Water" from Modern Times. What do I expect from Bob? Hasn’t he given me enough? I can pore over this man’s catalogue for the next several years and not fully digest it all. A line from the intro to Bob’s lives shows says, "… suddenly shifted gears, releasing some of the strongest music of his career, beginning in the late 90s." Time Out Of Mind won the Grammy for album of the year and Bob has been highly regarded with his last three releases. Like Johnny Cash, Bob Dylan is a national treasure who has refused to lie down and die, instead staying hungry and writing and recording material that is worthy of his heralded early work.
It has been forty years since Blonde On Blonde. Over forty since "Blowin’ In The Wind" and "Like A Rolling Stone." I am too young to know the hugeness of those releases. I have only history to tell me what a shock it was when "Dylan plugged in and went electric." While I can appreciate the context of all that, I can only see it and hear it from the distant past. I will never know the impact of first hearing a song like "Like A Rolling Stone" on the radio. I will never realize what it meant when Bob became born again. People have put Bob on a pedestal, and they have torn him off, only to place him right back on it again. I don’t think he likes being put up there anyway. The bottom line is this: Those moments were events. My parents got to appreciate those events. They got to live those events. Events that I can only read about or see on television.
In 2006, with Modern Times (like Love And Theft before it), these are our events. Moments that are our own. I know that Bob is for everybody. This is why I cannot claim them for my own. They are ours. Bob Dylan is just as important over forty years later. He is still giving us strong material that will stand alongside our parent’s moments.
Bob recorded Modern Times with his current touring band (my personal favorite band I’ve seen him with): Tony Garnier, George Receli, Stu Kimball, Denny Freeman, and Donnie Herron. Like Love and Theft before, he also produced the album himself under the nom de plume Jack Frost. The cohesiveness of this band shines through every track as it swings through folk, rockabilly, and blues. This music is timeless and holds no place under strict stylistic filing.
I prefer Bob’s modern growl to even the earlier nasal snarl that adorned his earlier work. That war-worn voice has seen better days, but it’s weary enough that you hang onto every word as if it were coming from someone wiser and more prophetic than anyone you’ve ever know. When Bob says that he’s looking for Alicia Keys on the first track, "Thunder On The Mountain," you can’t help but to believe it as opposed to tossing it off into the modern era of hip "shout-outs." The track has a powerful Chuck Berry backbeat that adds more power to Bob’s strong lyrics.
The band eases into the shuffle of "Spirit On The Water" like an old well-worn shoe. It can be compared to the romantic "Moonlight" on Love And Theft. The words match the romance as Bob professes his profound love for the song’s subject. "If I can’t have you, I’ll throw my love into the deep, blue sea."
"Rollin’ And Tumblin’" is Bob’s tribute to Muddy Waters. It’s blues as strong as anything on Highway 61 Revisited. The big difference is that those blues may have been slightly forced, more of an exploration. These blues are lived-in and speaks from experience. Its chugs along at a steady tempo and it never steps out of line. The band is locked in and locked down.
Bob is back to love "When The Deal Goes Down." Here, he is making the life-long pact that he will be by his lover’s side. It’s futile to decipher who or what Bob is always talking about, but it’s incredible to hear his balance of God and love. This has been an ongoing element to his songs since the controversial "Gospel period."
The tempo picks back up with rockabilly backbeat of "Someday Baby." This time, Bob’s got leaving on the brain. He just can’t handle the women he so deeply loves. Again, behind Bob’s lyrics and voice, the band keeps things in check with some of the most tasteful soloing committed to tape in the last ten years. "Someday, baby, you’re not gonna be with me no more…"
"Workingman’s Blues #2" is not Bob’s sequel to Merle Haggard’s hit, but it could be. It’s an epic unto itself with one of Bob’s most beautiful melodies. Bob easily plays the part of preacher, romantic, and poet with equal fervor all in one song. He’s a student of song history and every bit of it shows through on this ballad.
The record moves right back into the easy shuffle of "Beyond The Horizon." This song could have been written in the 30s. Or the 50s. But it was written today. The lyrics take center stage again as Bob tells us, "Beyond the horizon, I found you just in time." It’s all about not believing that one can still be so in love after everything one has been through.
In a perfect world, "Nettie Moore" would be the hit single associated with this record. However, Bob is above writing hits and certainly cannot be bothered. The soft thud of the bass drum gives way to a lilting chorus of longing and loss. This is pure musical poetry. Anyone who needs proof that Bob Dylan has still got it, take one listen to "Nettie Moore." I’m certain this song will take its rightful place in Bob’s laundry list of great material.
Bob returns to flood waters with the blues-shuffle of "The Levee’s Gonna Break." You could easily apply the lyrics to the recent events in New Orleans, but I’m almost positive that Bob was just rewriting another old blues song. Led Zeppelin this ain’t.
The album closes with the ballad "Ain’t Talkin'." Bob tells us that he’s through talking and that he just wants to be left alone. By giving up talking, he’s saying a lot. The track is as righteous and indignant as Johnny Cash is at his most forthright. It swaggers and makes a powerful statement about the state of affairs of whatever you want them to be. One of the great truths of Bob is that you can apply them almost anywhere to any situation.
Some of the things I’ve read concerning Modern Times is that it could easily be the third part of a trilogy that began with Time Out Of Mind. I think it’s only the third-in-a-row album of very strong Bob Dylan performances and material. Stylistically, Modern Times is closer to Love and Theft than Love and Theft is to Time Out of Mind. So, if anything, Modern Times is a sequel to Love And Theft and we’ve yet to hear the third part. Here’s hoping we get it.
"Strongest music of his career" indeed. Bob Dylan is not yours or mine. He’s all of ours, thank God.
Relationship with God throughout Modern Times
No Rating
Well said propertyofjesus, and nice username. I've reached some of the very same insights about these songs as you have, though I would venture somewhat more specific, and consequently more risky, interpretations. Let me take Spirit on the Water as one great example, I think you hint at what I'm going to flesh out.
I think Spirit on the Water might be a love song between God and the Jewish people, all the way from creation (spirit hovering over the waters, darkness on the face of the deep), through God's longsuffering mercy for His people despite their fickleness ("do good all day, wrong all night"; also there's a reference to the future suffering God would do for His people and all mankind, in His Son's 'sweating blood" before his Crucifixion), through God's willingness to pay any price to be with His people and the joy there is when they are together, through His desire to be with His people "ever since the world began," and finally to the "falling out" between God and the Jewish people (as an entity, to say nothing of individual Jews) when they reject His Son (extensively discussed by Paul - a Jew - in his epistles). Importantly, God "won't be back until fall;" that is, in the "fall" He may return to the Jewish people, meaning they might return to Him eventually (as suggested by Paul as well); also the last stanza suggests God will always take back those who repent; no sin of ours can outdate God; He is never over the hill or past His prime; he can field any fly ball we hit at Him.
And the bridge stanza (3rd stanza of each verse) perhaps represents the response of the Jewish people (though it could just as well be God's peoplein general) throughout history, sometimes forgetful of God, sometimes loving, sometimes insecure, sometimes doubtful; but it wouldn't be a love song if only God were speaking; our free will response if required. And in the last verse, there's a beautiful interplay as the Jewish people echo the lines of the good thief on the cross, but with a twist: "Well, I really DO want to be with you in Paradise, and it really DOES seem unfair, doesn't it? But I can't go to paradise no more; you see, I killed a man (Jesus) back there." This may be a sort of excuse to avoid repentance. I killed the Son of God; how could I ever be with You in paradise now? Of course, as mentioned before, God only asks us to repent and show Him "what we got;" we can still "have a whoppin' good time," regardless of the great magnitude and quantity of our sins.
This song might also be a love song between God and the True Israel, that is, both the original Israel, and then after Jesus, the New Israel, the Church. That was my original interpretation, but after some consideration, I lean towards the one given above more, especially given the last verse.
What's great about this song is that regardless of whether you buy into my admittedly out-there interpretation (though there's definitely a strong relgious element in this song), the song still works great as simply a love song between a man and a woman; and the production and instrumentation is just beautiful, to say nothing of the chord changes and melody. The instrumental verse at the end almost brings me to tears sometimes, especially if you see the harp as representing God's voice, and the guitar as our voice (which is as it should be, according to my interpretation); the way the harp subtly plays a few notes during the guitar solo, sort of guiding the process of human history, and then comes in almost impatiently as the guitar is finishing is fantastic.
I wish I had time to get to some other songs, since this is in a way almost a minor song on the album, at least lengthwise! haha "Ain't Talkin' would take a decade to flesh out all the detail there: just to give a taste, there's that line about "toothache in my heel." So obscure, huh? Not if we look at Genesis 3... Perhaps "fangache" would be more accurate?
What Love & theft should have been
As I said that World gone wrong was what Good as i been to you should have been I think that Modern times is what Love & theft should have been. The concept is similar: reminds of ancient music, "stolen" lyrics, the same band... The voice isn't still what it should but far better than 5 years before, and much more interesting songs. Ain't talkin' and Nettie Moore are the best for me but every song works except The leevee's gonna break, that reminds me too much of other songs, like Summer days or Cat's in the well.
Modern Times
It's been five years since Bob's last studio album, but he's hardly been idle in the meantime. There's the soundtrack for Masked & Anonymous full of covers (by Bob, of Bob, or both). There's his delightfully selective autobiography Chronicles, Vol. 1. He's dusted off yet more archives for another three volumes of the Bootleg Series. The always forward-thinking Mr. Zimmerman even agreed to concentrate solely on the per-motorcycle crash years for the Martin Scorcese documentary No Direction Home. After all this scrapbooking, it was exciting to look forward to something new from Bob. But alas, the title Modern Times is but a joke. What we've got here is Love & Theft vol. II. Another self-produced effort featuring his talented but anonymous touring band. We've still got the latest slang sounding anachronistic coming out of Dylan's mouth (Lazy slut? Alicia Keys?) Once again we're alternating between up-tempo rock-blues shuffles and swinging jazz crooner ballads (with perhaps even more of the later). "Levee's Gonna Break" even apes Love & Theft's "Highwater" in lyrical content about another apocalyptic flood. About the biggest surprise here is the harmonica solo at the end of "Spirit On The Water", we didn't heard Bob's harp on Love & Theft. Now, Bob repeating himself isn't necessarily a new or bad thing. He's done it often enough in the past. And Modern Times is pretty good. But after such a long wait and such prolonged (if pleasantly unexpected) focus on his past glories, I was really looking forward to hearing what new weirdness Bob was going to get into. Hopefully the next album really will be a reflection on modern times and not just a willful ignorance of them.
One of my favorite albums,
One of my favorite albums, especially Workingman's Blues #2, Nettie Moore and Thunder on the Mountain
A Great Album
"Modern Times" seems to me to be especially about "memory". Throughout the album, Dylan seems to be remembering the past while, at the same time, recognizing that the fast pace of "Modern Times" really leaves "no time to think". This can be seen in each of the songs:
- "Thunder on the Mountain" is, among other things, a reaffirmation and reevaluation of the beliefs Dylan proclaimed while he was "livin' down the line" ("Some sweet day I'll stand beside my King", "Remember this, I'm your servant both night and day", "I've already confessed, no need to confess again").
- "Spirit on the Water", "When the Deal Goes Down", and "Nettie Moore" use biblical references to the beginning and end of creation to allude to the longing for a lover from the distant past and the desire to spend eternity with her (it could also be seen to be about a Groom still waiting at the altar)
- "Rollin' and Tumblin'" is, among other things, a song about forgiving and reconciling
- "Someday Baby" - A mocking, condensing song to earthly temptation, or the devil, or whatever has plagued Dylan his entire life, and Dylan's desire to be free from its power.
- Working Man Blues - In the face of the stresses of "modern times", "the place I love best is a sweet memory"
- The Levee Gonna Break - A song about the tragedy of life forcing us to never stop moving, even when it means parting with loved ones
- Ain't Talkin' - Wow. The masterpiece of this album. Continuing the theme of "Levee" and "Thunder on the Mountain", this song is about retaining firm in footing and staying true to oneself and to one's God, no matter how dark it gets.
Anyway, that’s the way I see it. Someone else can obviously see things in a different light when they look through the multi-faceted prism that is Bob Dylan.
Genius Lyrical Borrowing
No Rating
This album has been criticized for 'stealing' lyrics from other artists. My take is this: No new song is truly original or made in a vacum. Dylan, better than almost any other current artist, has recognized throughout his career the immense debt that he owes to previous generations of musicians and song writers. From his first album to his latest, the voices of older artists echo through Dylan's music. Dylan doesn't hide the music he borrows (or, as I see it, the music he builds upon). He celebrates these artists and admits, at the same time, his small status in comparison to his musical forefathers/mothers.
Dylan may think his status is small in comparison, but judging merely by how many other artists have "borrowed" his style/music/lyrics/material in the past decades, Dylan already stands among the legendary greats.
But no one can sing the blues like Blind Willie McTell.